AI assistant
EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LTD — Major Shareholding Notification 2020
Aug 26, 2020
64816_rns_2020-08-26_07aea5d1-1a6b-42e7-aaa9-278b94ee818a.pdf
Major Shareholding Notification
Open in viewerOpens in your device viewer
page 1/2 15 July 2001 603
Form 603
Corporations Act 2001 Section 671B
Notice of initial substantial holder
| To Company Name/Scheme | Excelsior Capital Ltd (ASX:ECL) | |
|---|---|---|
| ACN/ARSN | 050 542 553 | |
| 1. Details of substantial holder (1) Name ACN/ARSN (if applicable) |
Warwick Sauer | |
| The holder became a substantial holder on | 24 / 08 / 2020 |
2. Details of voting power
The total number of votes attached to all the voting shares in the company or voting interests in the scheme that the substantial holder or an associate (2) had a relevant interest (3) in on the date the substantial holder became a substantial holder are as follows:
| Class of securities (4) | Number of securities | Person's votes (5) | Voting power (6) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ordinary shares | 1630093 | 1630093 | 5.62% |
3. Details of relevant interests
The nature of the relevant interest the substantial holder or an associate had in the following voting securities on the date the substantial holder became a substantial holder are as follows:
| Holder of relevant interest | Nature of relevant interest (7) | Class and number of securities |
|---|---|---|
| See Annexure A | See Annexure A | See Annexure A |
4. Details of present registered holders
The persons registered as holders of the securities referred to in paragraph 3 above are as follows:
| Holder of relevant interest |
Registered holder of securities |
Person entitled to be registered as holder (8) |
Class and number of securities |
|---|---|---|---|
| See Annexure A | See Annexure A | See Annexure A | See Ann. Al |
5. Consideration
The consideration paid for each relevant interest referred to in paragraph 3 above, and acquired in the four months prior to the day that the substantial holder became a substantial holder is as follows:
| Holder of relevant interest |
Date of acquisition | Consideration (9) | Class and number of securities |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cash | Non-cash | |||
| See Annexure B | See Annexure B | See Annexure B | ⊺See Ann. B | |
603 page 2/2 15 July 2001
| Name and ACN/ARSN (if applicable) | Nature of association | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| See Annexure C | See Annexure C | |||||
| 7. Addresses | ||||||
| The addresses of persons named in this form are as follows: | ||||||
| Name | Address | |||||
| See Annexure D | See Annexure D | |||||
| Signature | ||||||
| print name | Warwick Sauer | capacity Self |
||||
| sign here | 26/08/2020 date |
|||||
| DIRECTIONS | ||||||
| (1) | form. | If there are a number of substantial holders with similar or related relevant interests (eg. a corporation and its related corporations, or the manager and trustee of an equity trust), the names could be included in an annexure to the form. If the relevant interests of a group of persons are essentially similar, they may be referred to throughout the form as a specifically named group if the membership of each group, with the names and addresses of members is clearly set out in paragraph 7 of the |
||||
| (2) | See the definition of "associate" in section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001. | |||||
| (3) | See the definition of "relevant interest" in sections 608 and 671B(7) of the Corporations Act 2001. | |||||
| $\langle 4 \rangle$ | The voting shares of a company constitute one class unless divided into separate classes. | |||||
| (5) | interest in. | The total number of votes attached to all the voting shares in the company or voting interests in the scheme (if any) that the person or an associate has a relevant | ||||
| (6) | The person's votes divided by the total votes in the body corporate or scheme multiplied by 100. | |||||
| (7) | Include details of: | |||||
| (a) | this form, together with a written statement certifying this contract, scheme or arrangement; and | any relevant agreement or other circumstances by which the relevant interest was acquired. If subsection 671B(4) applies, a copy of any document setting out the terms of any relevant agreement, and a statement by the person giving full and accurate details of any contract, scheme or arrangement, must accompany |
||||
| (D) | any qualification of the power of a person to exercise, control the exercise of, or influence the exercise of, the voting powers or disposal of the securities to which the relevant interest relates (indicating clearly the particular securities to which the qualification applies). |
|||||
| See the definition of "relevant agreement" in section 9 of the Corporations Act 2001. | ||||||
| (8) | If the substantial holder is unable to determine the identity of the person (eg. if the relevant interest anses because of an option) write "unknown". |
THIS IS ANNEXURE A AS REFERRED TO IN THE FORM 603 LODGED IN RELATION TO EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LIMITED ABN 98 050 542 553
| Holder of Relevant Interest |
Person Entitled to be Registered as Holder |
Nature of Relevant Interest |
Number of shares held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warwick Sauer | Warwick Sauer | Direct holdings | 561938 |
| Vera Kalabric | Vera Kalabric | Direct holdings | 135000 |
| Kalabric Family Super Pty Ltd atf the Kalabric Superfund |
Kalabric Family Super Pty Ltd |
Direct holdings held as trustee |
310000 |
| Benjamin Graham and Katerina Graham att the FKR Super Fund |
Benjamin Graham and Katerina Graham |
Direct holdings held as trustee |
180000 |
| Whiley Close Investment Pty Ltd atf the Sims Family Super Fund |
Whiley Close Investment Pty Ltd |
Direct holdings held as trustee |
130000 |
| BAVARIA Industries Group AG ("BIG") |
Interactive Brokers Australia Pty Ltd / BNP Paribas Securities Services Australia as custodian |
BIG has the power to control the exercise of the right to vote the shares, and the power to exercise control over the disposal of the shares |
313153 |
THIS IS ANNEXURE B AS REFERRED TO IN THE FORM 603 LODGED IN RELATION TO EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LIMITED ABN 98 050 542 553
| Date of change |
Person whose relevant interest changed |
Nature of change | Consideration given in relation to change |
Shares bought |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Warwick Sauer | Purchase of shares | \$76 015 41 | 62607 | |
| Vera Kalabric | Sale of shares | -\$56,400.00 | $-45000$ | |
| Various | Kalabric Family Super Pty Ltd atf the Kalabric Superfund |
Purchase of shares | \$120,006.09 | 90000 |
| dates from 24/4/20 |
Benjamin Graham and Katerina Graham atf the FKR Super Fund |
N/A | nil | n |
| to 24/8/20 |
Whiley Close Investment Pty Ltd atf the Sims Family Super Fund |
Purchase of shares | \$154,440.00 | 130000 |
| BAVARIA Industries Group AG |
Purchase of shares | \$374,217.84 | 313153 |
26 August 2020
圓 4 of 10
THIS IS ANNEXURE C AS REFERRED TO IN THE FORM 603 LODGED IN RELATION TO EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LIMITED ABN 98 050 542 553
On 24 August 2020, by the attachment comprising Annexure E, the parties listed in Annexure A jointly requested the directors of Excelsior Capital Ltd to call and arrange to hold a meeting of the members of Excelsior Capital Ltd to consider and vote on the following proposed resolution:
That pursuant to Sections 491 and 495 of the Corporations Act, Excelsior Capital Limited be voluntarily wound up and that James Taplin and Stefan Dopking of BRI Ferrier, having consented to act, are hereby appointed liquidators of Excelsior Capital Limited.
The parties listed in Annexure A have agreed to work together to put forward and promote the resolution. For this reason, they consider themselves to be associates.
THIS IS ANNEXURE D AS REFERRED TO IN THE FORM 603 LODGED IN RELATION TO EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LIMITED ABN 98 050 542 553
| Name of holder | Address |
|---|---|
| Warwick Sauer | c/ PO Box 573, Paddington, Qld 4064 |
| Vera Kalabric | 90 Evelyn St, Sylvania, NSW 2224 |
| Kalabric Family Super Pty Ltd atf the Kalabric Superfund |
90 Evelyn St, Sylvania, NSW 2224 |
| Benjamin Graham and Katerina Graham atf the FKR Super Fund |
c/ GPO Box 9981, Adelaide, SA 5001 |
| Whiley Close Investment Pty Ltd atf the Sims Family Super Fund |
Level 1/58-60 Glebe Road, The Junction, NSW, 2291 |
| BAVARIA Industries Group AG | Bavariaring 24, 80336 Munich, Germany |
THIS IS ANNEXURE E AS REFERRED TO IN ANNEXURE C TO THE FORM 603 LODGED IN RELATION TO EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LIMITED ABN 98 050 542 553
REQUEST FOR DIRECTORS OF EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LTD TO CALL A GENERAL MEETING OF EXCELSIOR CAPITAL LTD
To: Excelsior Capital Ltd ("ECL")
The following members of ECL hold at least 5% of the votes that may be cast at the requested general meeting:
- $\mathbf{1}$ . Mr Warwick Sauer.
- $\overline{2}$ . Mrs Vera Kalabric;
- $3.$ Kalabric Family Super Pty Ltd atf the Kalabric Superfund;
- $\overline{4}$ . Mr Benjamin Graham and Mrs Katerina Graham atf the FKR Super Fund;
- $5.$ Whiley Close Investment Pty Ltd at fthe Sims Family Super Fund;
-
- BAVARIA Industries Group AG,
(the Requisitioning Shareholders).
The Requisitioning Shareholders request under section 249D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) that the directors of ECL call and arrange to hold a meeting of the members of ECL to consider and vote on the following resolution:
That pursuant to Sections 491 and 495 of the Corporations Act, Excelsior Capital Limited be voluntarily wound up and that James Taplin and Stefan Dopking of BRI Ferrier, having consented to act, are hereby appointed liquidators of Excelsior Capital Limited.
Enclosed is a statement prepared by the Requisitioning Shareholders in accordance with section 249P of the Act. The Requisitioning Shareholders request that ECL provide this statement to all members of ECL along with the notice of the meeting requested in this document.
Dated: 24 August 2020
MEMBERS' STATEMENT
24 August 2020
Vote
FOR
the Resolution
Dear Fellow ECL Shareholder,
We recently asked ECL's directors to arrange a meeting of shareholders to consider selling ECL's electrical business. ECL's directors refused to arrange that meeting, then in the same breath, admitted that ECL's "board has been actively engaged in an internal and external review of the Company's investments since the first quarter of 2020" [sic], and that it "has appointed external advisors for both divestment and growth opportunities".
ECL's two main assets are its electrical business and its investment portfolio. Recent sale prices of businesses like ECL's electrical business suggest it alone is worth \$1.75 to \$2.40+ per share. The investments are worth another ≈65c per share, making ECL's total value $\approx$ \$2.40 - \$3.05. However, before we asked for that first meeting. shares in ECL were trading at around \$1.20.
So why don't ECL shares trade vastly higher?
We think investors avoid ECL because they have serious concerns about how ECL has been run, and they do not see things changing.
The resolution we are now proposing would guarantee change, through liquidation of ECL and payment of its true worth to all shareholders.
Here are some examples of ECL's history.
- Catelan entities acquired nearly 10% of ECL in one transaction, without offering to buy the whole company - breaching the Corporations Act.
ECL shareholders raised this with the Australian Government's Takeovers Panel. Despite the Catelan entities arguing otherwise, the Panel declared it to be "Unacceptable Circumstances".
The Catelan entities didn't accept that, and demanded a review. The Panel reiterated it was "Unacceptable Circumstances".
The Catelan entities didn't accept that, and appealed to the Federal Court. And the Federal Court confirmed, again, it was "Unacceptable Circumstances".
This history matters hugely to investors, because interests of Leanne Catelan now hold nearly half ECL's shares.
2. ECL resisted fixing its capital structure until being forced to
For years, ECL had both ordinary shares and Preference / Class A shares.
Also for years, ECL paid a dividend of \$nil on the Preference / Class A shares. Thus, despite being originally sold for \$1.20, those shares traded on ASX around 40c.
It took a long-fought campaign by a major shareholder to force change. That shareholder requisitioned two separate meetings, and sued ECL and its directors (including current directors Leanne Catelan and Danny Herceg) in Queensland's Supreme Court.
After "vigorously defending" the lawsuit for months, ECL capitulated and said it would pay Class A shareholders 95c per share. Also, ECL and other defendants paid over \$500,000 towards the complaining shareholder's legal costs.
- ECL created an "investment portfolio" against the wishes of most shareholders, and that portfolio has massively underperformed
Late in 2016, ECL proposed putting over \$20m - the vast majority of its cash - into an "investment portfolio", with eye-watering fees payable to its manager.
Excluding the >13.8m shares held by interests of Leanne Catelan, over 82% of shareholder votes cast on this proposal opposed it. The Catelan votes however ensured the proposal passed.
Since its creation, the "investment portfolio" has performed terribly, gaining just 1.96% versus the ASX's All Ordinaries Accumulation Index's >21% as at 30 June.
- ECL's board is a revolving door
The table below details movements in ECL's directorial and secretarial positions since August 2011. The longer someone oversees a business, the more they learn about it - and deeper knowledge produces better decision-making. Yet many of ECL's directors have served for mere months (and on one occasion, for just two months). Is it any surprise that that might be of grave concern to investors? Why have so many directors quit so soon after being appointed?
| Date | Appointed | Ceased | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2011 -$ August |
Leanne | Ray Catelan | |
| Catelan | Richard Catelan | ||
| $2012 -$ February |
Somerville | ||
| June | Somerville | Served ~four months | |
| December | Lonie | ||
| $2013 -$ February |
Lonie | Served ~two months | |
| March | Ryan | Forced out upon criminal conviction |
|
| Williams | |||
| May | Rolfe | ||
| $2014 -$ April |
Rolfe | Served <12 months | |
| Buckley | |||
| Herceg | |||
| Forbes | |||
| Williams | Served 13 months | ||
| 2015-December | Buckley | Served 20 months | |
| 2016 - February | Green | ||
| Forbes | Served 22 months | ||
| March | Miotti | ||
| December | Williams* | ||
| Glennon | |||
| Sandham* |
| $2017 -$ February |
Miotti | Served <12 months | |
|---|---|---|---|
| October | Sandham* | Served <12 months | |
| Cohen* | |||
| 2018 - December | Cohen* | Served ~14 months | |
| Glennon* | |||
| $2019 -$ May |
Glennon* | Served ~5 months | |
| Copeland* | |||
| September | Green | ||
| Copeland | |||
| October | Glennon | ||
| Herceg | |||
| $2020 -$ January |
Cohen* | ||
| Copeland | |||
| Schweizer | |||
| Copeland* | Served ~8 months |
*company secretary role
So what is the solution?
If our resolution is passed, ECL will sell its assets (including the electrical business), pay out its debts, and finally, pay shareholders all of the money that then remains.
We understand that potential acquirers of the electrical business have approached ECL about potentially buying it, but ECL has engaged with them either minimally or not at all.
Businesses like ECL's electrical business change hands regularly. Based on recent sales, we think ECL's electrical business is worth \$50m at an absolute minimum, and perhaps even \$70m or more - ie \$1.75 to \$2.40+ per ECL share. That is in addition to the "investment portfolio" worth ≈65c per share.
By voting for our resolution, you will be voting for the true value of ECL to go into your hip pocket - where that money belongs.
We think the decision is easy. Risk your shares being perennially undervalued, and accept that undervalue if you sell them. Or - vote for the resolution, to unlock ECL's huge intrinsic value.
Who are we?
We are ECL shareholders just like you. Together we have around \$2,000,000 invested in ECL - so our interests are wholly aligned with yours.
Your vote is important!
Retaining the status quo may result in ECL's share price continuing to reflect investors' concerns about how the company has been managed. This is your opportunity to change that.
We look forward to your participation at the meeting and your vote in favour of the resolution.
We would welcome contact from fellow investors. Our e-mail address is [email protected].
Sincerely,
Warwick, Vera, Elvis, Ben, Katerina, and Daniel